Roof Coatings vs. Tear-Off: When Restoration Should Win

Jake Stolzfus • August 20, 2025

How Wisconsin businesses can save money, time, and headaches with roof coatings instead of full replacements.

The Dilemma: Replace or Restore?

Every building owner eventually faces the same question: Is it time to replace the roof, or can it be restored? In Wisconsin, where commercial roofs face everything from heavy snow loads to sweltering summer heat, this decision is critical—and costly. While full tear-offs and replacements have their place, modern roof coating systems often provide a smarter, more affordable solution.


What Are Roof Coatings?

Roof coatings are seamless, liquid-applied membranes that restore existing flat and low-slope roofs. They create a protective barrier against leaks, UV rays, and ponding water. Unlike replacement, coatings don’t require removing your existing roof system—saving time, money, and disruption.


The Benefits of Choosing Coatings Over Replacement

  • Lower Cost – Coatings are typically 50–70% less expensive than a full tear-off and replacement.
  • Less Disruption – No dumpsters, no loud demolition, and no weeks of construction. Your business keeps running while we work.
  • Extended Roof Life – A properly applied coating can add 10–20 years of service life to your roof.
  • Energy Savings – White or reflective coatings reduce heat absorption, keeping interiors cooler and lowering utility bills.
  • Eco-Friendly – Restoration reduces landfill waste by reusing your existing roof system instead of sending tons of debris to the dump.


When Replacement Still Makes Sense

Roof coatings aren’t a magic fix for every situation. If your roof is structurally unsound, has multiple saturated insulation layers, or has already failed repeatedly, replacement may be the only option. That’s why a professional inspection is essential—we help you weigh the options honestly.


Real Results in Wisconsin

At Premier Roof Solutions, we’ve restored dozens of commercial roofs across Shullsburg, Cottage Grove, and Southern Wisconsin. From warehouses to retail spaces, coatings have saved our clients tens of thousands of dollars while extending the life of their buildings.


Make the Smart Choice This Summer

Before you commit to a costly tear-off, find out if your roof can be restored instead. Coatings are faster, cleaner, and budget-friendly—making them the right choice for many Wisconsin businesses.


Contact Premier Roof Solutions today for a free inspection and honest assessment of your roof’s condition. Let’s find the solution that works best for your business.

newly restored metal roof in Madison, Wisconsin
By Jake Stolzfus July 14, 2025
Roof Coatings 101: Save Money with Restoration Instead of Replacement
commercial warehouse with a new replacement commercial roof
By Jake Stolzfus June 23, 2025
What Facility Directors Need to Know About Energy-Efficient Roofing